Thursday, November 11, 2010

Not My Best Idea

A couple of Blogs ago I announced that I was going to try the idea of getting the students to write questions for their own assessment.
Disaster would be a good way to describe the outcome.  An idea that was considered great at the time, after reading about it from research material, certainly didn't work as expected.  Problems were encountered at every step.  1 student out of 12 managed to complete the task.
Stage 1 involved a half hour lesson on what was required and tips on question writing.  Their homework was to revise the work we had covered over the last 3 weeks and write 3 questions with answers to be included in the next assessment.  They could use any resources that were given, hand outs, past assessments etc:   A date for completion was set.
I sat back in anticipation to watch the work roll in. 
3 students arrived with the task completed, the rest had not completed it due to an array of wonderful excuses.  Less than happy with the result I set the task again.  This time, to be completed in class.  My timing was way off.  I allowed half an hour to write 3 questions.  Some were still at it after an hour.
The results left me rather despondent.  Some of the questions were so obscure that I could not understand how they arrived at the answer.
On reflection:  the students have undertaken extra revision.  I have some insight into their thinking,  some of the questions were very difficult and of a higher level than expected. 
It looks like the bulk of the assessment questions will come from my pen.

Was it a waste of time ?  No and certainly don't dismiss it. 
I would do things differently next time and bring the exercise in at the beginning of the course, not the end.  This way they would develop a better understanding of the process and be hopefully formulating questions in their heads as the course progresses.

Next idea.......'Blackboard Rugby'

No comments:

Post a Comment