The course on Assessment has finished and we all gave a presentation about our Bloggs and other experiences.
Some of us spoke for much longer than needed. Stefan could not find my off switch.
While this blog was started as a requirement for our Assessment course I am inclined to keep it going and branch out to other areas that could be of interest.
For example I was keen to carry on discussions with Kate's wiki page that mentioned placebos in nursing and the ethical implications.
Some of my previous courses have involved studies into psychology and human behaviour. Two subjects that I find intriguing.
To this end we spent sometime researching the effects of placebos. The concept as stated by a Waikato Hospital doctor that 80% of healing is carried out in the mind was discussed along with the reverse that
perhaps 80% of patient symptoms are manifested in the head.
Hmmmm???
Graphicman
Wednesday, December 8, 2010
Sunday, December 5, 2010
Food for Thought
Carrying on from the talk titled "Do Schools Kill Creativity" by Sir Ken Robinson, you may be interested in the RSA Animates portrayal of his talk titled 'Changing Education Paradigms.
Check it out www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U
I found it quiet thought provoking and suggests changing our approach to education for the future.
Check it out www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U
I found it quiet thought provoking and suggests changing our approach to education for the future.
Monday, November 29, 2010
Self Fulfilling Prophecy
This has little to do with Assessment but I found it quiet interesting. While looking through the work of Professor Daniel Willingham there is reference made to a bloke called Gardner.
He claims that there is no link between genetics and subject ability.
Just because one (or both) of your parents were low achievers in a particular subject does not mean the children will be low achievers.
His research points to the suggestion of 'suggeston'. It is self fullilling prophecy. If you are told from an early age that everyone in your family is poor at maths there is a likely hood you will also believe you are inadequate in that subject and perform accordingly.
Teachers need to continuously promote a positive attitude and ensure the students have a good experience.
Makes sense !
Telling students that the assessment they are about to undertake could end their career may have a similar effect and raise anxiety.
He claims that there is no link between genetics and subject ability.
Just because one (or both) of your parents were low achievers in a particular subject does not mean the children will be low achievers.
His research points to the suggestion of 'suggeston'. It is self fullilling prophecy. If you are told from an early age that everyone in your family is poor at maths there is a likely hood you will also believe you are inadequate in that subject and perform accordingly.
Teachers need to continuously promote a positive attitude and ensure the students have a good experience.
Makes sense !
Telling students that the assessment they are about to undertake could end their career may have a similar effect and raise anxiety.
Learning Styles Debate
Having invested a lot of time attending a course and applying the VARK theory on learning styles I was rather taken back when Stefan comes along with his opinion that VARK is largely a load of 'rubbish'
VARK was the trendy new idea that made sense, and, I embraced it as a clever psychological approach to getting the best out of students. My understanding of it changed to accept that it did not apply to all students, but all in all, it made sense........until.....Stefan.!! He backed up his statement with facts and the most recent research by professor Daniel T. Willingham. (check out www.danielwillingham.com and YouTube 'Learning styles don't exist'.)
This professor has carried out some very compelling research that shows there is no conclusive evidence that people will learn better if they are taught in their suggested learning style...yet he also found that 90% of teachers believe in VARK.
How can it be wrong if some many people believe it to be true ?
He shows that learning styles are best related to the subject that is taught.
- Languages and Music rely on Auditory learning stlyes.
- Sciences need Visual and Kinesthetic.
- Art, of course, would be Visual.
His approach is that a lesson should be constructed around the learning styles best suited to that subject.
VARK exists, not as a learning style, but as a teaching style.
Hang On!!! Could my approach to assessment be out of date as well ? Do I rely too much on written assessments ?
The good thing about written assessment is that I have evidence that I can ponder at a later date or use to support decision.
After more exposure to Professor Willingham findings I am convinced to try assessing which involves taking notes of oral questioning and notes while observing student practical work.
VARK was the trendy new idea that made sense, and, I embraced it as a clever psychological approach to getting the best out of students. My understanding of it changed to accept that it did not apply to all students, but all in all, it made sense........until.....Stefan.!! He backed up his statement with facts and the most recent research by professor Daniel T. Willingham. (check out www.danielwillingham.com and YouTube 'Learning styles don't exist'.)
This professor has carried out some very compelling research that shows there is no conclusive evidence that people will learn better if they are taught in their suggested learning style...yet he also found that 90% of teachers believe in VARK.
How can it be wrong if some many people believe it to be true ?
He shows that learning styles are best related to the subject that is taught.
- Languages and Music rely on Auditory learning stlyes.
- Sciences need Visual and Kinesthetic.
- Art, of course, would be Visual.
His approach is that a lesson should be constructed around the learning styles best suited to that subject.
VARK exists, not as a learning style, but as a teaching style.
Hang On!!! Could my approach to assessment be out of date as well ? Do I rely too much on written assessments ?
The good thing about written assessment is that I have evidence that I can ponder at a later date or use to support decision.
After more exposure to Professor Willingham findings I am convinced to try assessing which involves taking notes of oral questioning and notes while observing student practical work.
Thursday, November 11, 2010
Not My Best Idea
A couple of Blogs ago I announced that I was going to try the idea of getting the students to write questions for their own assessment.
Disaster would be a good way to describe the outcome. An idea that was considered great at the time, after reading about it from research material, certainly didn't work as expected. Problems were encountered at every step. 1 student out of 12 managed to complete the task.
Stage 1 involved a half hour lesson on what was required and tips on question writing. Their homework was to revise the work we had covered over the last 3 weeks and write 3 questions with answers to be included in the next assessment. They could use any resources that were given, hand outs, past assessments etc: A date for completion was set.
I sat back in anticipation to watch the work roll in.
3 students arrived with the task completed, the rest had not completed it due to an array of wonderful excuses. Less than happy with the result I set the task again. This time, to be completed in class. My timing was way off. I allowed half an hour to write 3 questions. Some were still at it after an hour.
The results left me rather despondent. Some of the questions were so obscure that I could not understand how they arrived at the answer.
On reflection: the students have undertaken extra revision. I have some insight into their thinking, some of the questions were very difficult and of a higher level than expected.
It looks like the bulk of the assessment questions will come from my pen.
Was it a waste of time ? No and certainly don't dismiss it.
I would do things differently next time and bring the exercise in at the beginning of the course, not the end. This way they would develop a better understanding of the process and be hopefully formulating questions in their heads as the course progresses.
Next idea.......'Blackboard Rugby'
Disaster would be a good way to describe the outcome. An idea that was considered great at the time, after reading about it from research material, certainly didn't work as expected. Problems were encountered at every step. 1 student out of 12 managed to complete the task.
Stage 1 involved a half hour lesson on what was required and tips on question writing. Their homework was to revise the work we had covered over the last 3 weeks and write 3 questions with answers to be included in the next assessment. They could use any resources that were given, hand outs, past assessments etc: A date for completion was set.
I sat back in anticipation to watch the work roll in.
3 students arrived with the task completed, the rest had not completed it due to an array of wonderful excuses. Less than happy with the result I set the task again. This time, to be completed in class. My timing was way off. I allowed half an hour to write 3 questions. Some were still at it after an hour.
The results left me rather despondent. Some of the questions were so obscure that I could not understand how they arrived at the answer.
On reflection: the students have undertaken extra revision. I have some insight into their thinking, some of the questions were very difficult and of a higher level than expected.
It looks like the bulk of the assessment questions will come from my pen.
Was it a waste of time ? No and certainly don't dismiss it.
I would do things differently next time and bring the exercise in at the beginning of the course, not the end. This way they would develop a better understanding of the process and be hopefully formulating questions in their heads as the course progresses.
Next idea.......'Blackboard Rugby'
Tuesday, November 9, 2010
VARK the Students
During the course of our Tuesday night sessions the subject of VARK learning styles came up.
VARK = Visual, Auditory, Read/write, Kinaesthetic (touchy feely).
VARK had great popularity when it was first introduced, similar to CROCs, and as time has passed I believe that much of the starry eyed wonderment has receded to leave the few aspects that have practical use.
Stefan implied that he was not a great follower of the practise, something that I would have liked to discuss further.
It certainly is not the wonder tool to solve all learning issues. My use of it is mainly confined to lesson planning where I try to incorporate a little bit of everything. This makes the lesson more interesting for the students. The result is better student attention and knowledge retention.
As far as assessment is concerned I find it is great to keep in the back of my mind when presenting questions.
Would the question be better understood if it was posed using a drawing, a sound bite, a physical item or descriptive text?
Would the answer be better demonstrated by the student presenting written text, a physical item, a verbal answer or a design drawing ?
Another area where I have had success with VARK was with teaching students study techniques. My first step was to hand out a questionnaire to determine the students strongest learning styles. Normally 2 areas of VARK.
Instead of 'cramming' the books, the students were given study techniques that best suited their styles and instructed to spend just one and a half hours each night studying. This was broken down to either four 15 minute or three 20 minute periods with a 10 minute break between. In reality the students were spending just one hour studying. Studies show that the attention span peaks out at 20 minutes, any study after that is just mush.
Students stopped spending 2-4 hours studying, results improved and exam anxiety was down.
Unfortunately VARK is not the silver bullet to cure all ills. It will not work with all students and a student that has leaning towards a certain style may change a week later.
Another valuable tool is a knowledge of NLP (Neuro-Linguistic Programming). I will post my thoughts and views in an upcoming Blog.
Cheers
Rod
VARK = Visual, Auditory, Read/write, Kinaesthetic (touchy feely).
VARK had great popularity when it was first introduced, similar to CROCs, and as time has passed I believe that much of the starry eyed wonderment has receded to leave the few aspects that have practical use.
Stefan implied that he was not a great follower of the practise, something that I would have liked to discuss further.
It certainly is not the wonder tool to solve all learning issues. My use of it is mainly confined to lesson planning where I try to incorporate a little bit of everything. This makes the lesson more interesting for the students. The result is better student attention and knowledge retention.
As far as assessment is concerned I find it is great to keep in the back of my mind when presenting questions.
Would the question be better understood if it was posed using a drawing, a sound bite, a physical item or descriptive text?
Would the answer be better demonstrated by the student presenting written text, a physical item, a verbal answer or a design drawing ?
Another area where I have had success with VARK was with teaching students study techniques. My first step was to hand out a questionnaire to determine the students strongest learning styles. Normally 2 areas of VARK.
Instead of 'cramming' the books, the students were given study techniques that best suited their styles and instructed to spend just one and a half hours each night studying. This was broken down to either four 15 minute or three 20 minute periods with a 10 minute break between. In reality the students were spending just one hour studying. Studies show that the attention span peaks out at 20 minutes, any study after that is just mush.
Students stopped spending 2-4 hours studying, results improved and exam anxiety was down.
Unfortunately VARK is not the silver bullet to cure all ills. It will not work with all students and a student that has leaning towards a certain style may change a week later.
Another valuable tool is a knowledge of NLP (Neuro-Linguistic Programming). I will post my thoughts and views in an upcoming Blog.
Cheers
Rod
Wednesday, November 3, 2010
Face Validity
Here is a new phrase. One which woke me up at 2:30 am as my brain analyses the details. Personally I don't think it is worthy of disturbing sleep.
In a nutshell, Face Validity simply means keeping it relevant. For instance when teaching maths to engineering students if we subtract, multiply, divide and add, oranges, bananas, pineapples and pears, we might as well add a few cherries and call it a fruit salad. Engineers need relevance ie: nuts bolts and bits of steel to visualise a structure. Nurses need pills, potions, large needles, bandages, injured and sick people.
This approach is equally important in designing assessments as it is in structuring a lesson.
Rather than invent the wheel I like to utilise assessments that are already in existence, and have hopefully been moderated. Sharing information.
By simply removing the trade related details and replacing with those from another another trade the assessment makes more sense to the students. The level of understanding is improved along with the level of interest.
In a nutshell, Face Validity simply means keeping it relevant. For instance when teaching maths to engineering students if we subtract, multiply, divide and add, oranges, bananas, pineapples and pears, we might as well add a few cherries and call it a fruit salad. Engineers need relevance ie: nuts bolts and bits of steel to visualise a structure. Nurses need pills, potions, large needles, bandages, injured and sick people.
This approach is equally important in designing assessments as it is in structuring a lesson.
Rather than invent the wheel I like to utilise assessments that are already in existence, and have hopefully been moderated. Sharing information.
By simply removing the trade related details and replacing with those from another another trade the assessment makes more sense to the students. The level of understanding is improved along with the level of interest.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)